Australian small caps market – key investment themes from the March 2025 quarter

Equity market rotation or just a blip?

For equity markets, the March 2025 quarter has been the antithesis of the 2024 calendar year.

Globally, many of the popular 2024 investment themes, including a more resilient US economic growth outlook, moderating inflation and US exceptionalism, together with crowded trades, including the Magnificent 7 stocks, have made way to increased US policy uncertainty (due mainly to tariffs) and increasing US recession fears (off a low base) which has been a drag on US market performance. This has been partially offset by positive economic surprise outside of the US and the reallocation of investor capital to both European and Asian equity markets.

A similar rotation has been experienced domestically with many of the popular holdings held by Australian small cap managers, including technology, quality, growth and defensively exposed companies having underperformed over the quarter – this has been despite many continuing to deliver on, and even exceeding, market earnings expectations. There has been a clear investor theme to recycle capital from many of these crowded trades which are trading on elevated multiples relative to historical averages into cheaper quality stocks and/or value/cyclical companies with improving earnings momentum.

‘Winner takes all’ unwind?

Another key investment theme over the quarter has been the potential unwind of the ‘winner takes all’. Over the past two years, the market has been pricing in winners in select industries ‘taking all’ which has resulted in a material valuation re-rate for those companies that have been able to grow market share in a challenging macroeconomic environment. Some notable examples include HUB24 and Netwealth Group in the wealth management platform market, Temple & Webster in the online furniture market, JB Hi-Fi in the electronics retail market and REA Group in the online residential classified market.

The key question for investors is whether the ‘winner takes all’ thematic is likely to ‘fully’ play out? The takeover proposal of Doman Holdings Australia by CoStar Group during the quarter suggests ‘no’. Domain is the no.2 player in the domestic online real estate portal which has typically traded at a 25-30% discount to the market leader, REA Group, which has been growing volumes faster and generating better yields. However, over the past two years the relative P/E discount has widened to 50%-60% with the market pricing in REA continuing to take market share. CoStar Group, a US property marketplace, with a >US$30bn market cap with deeper marketing pockets relative to REA, looks to be attracted to the Australian online marketplace and thinks there is considerable value, lobbing a $4.20ps bid at 35% premium to the previous close price. In summary, we believe the ‘winner takes all’ thematic being priced in for select stocks is unjustified.

Consumer relief for stretched households?

Over the quarter, the trading updates from consumer discretionary exposed companies have been underwhelming given extended promotional activity during key sales periods. This has been driven by a more value conscious consumer in a cost-of-living environment which has impacted gross margins for the retailers, including Myer Holdings, Adairs and Accent Group.

The key question for investors whether there is a more optimistic outlook for the domestic consumer? CBA thinks so given strong employment, wage increases, moderating inflation and tax cuts which are expected to see improving disposable income and discretionary spending across different age cohorts.

The other key question for investors is whether the start of the domestic interest rate cutting cycle by the RBA will be positive for the consumer? Using New Zealand as an example suggests ‘no’. New Zealand has been approximately 6 months ahead of Australia with interest rate cuts from a peak of 5.5% in mid-2024 to 3.75% currently with Australia getting its first cut in February 2025 from 4.35% to 4.10%. The New Zealand experience showed optimism with the first interest rate cut although has quickly faded with a continuation of subdued retailer trading updates recently from the likes of Michael Hill International, KMD Brands and Biscoe Group. We see a risk of a shallow interest rate cutting cycle being flagged by the RBA having minimal positive impact to the challenged retail sector and prefer structural growth companies, notably Nick Scali.

The new ‘golden’ age for Australian small cap miners

The meteoric rise of the gold price has seen Australian small cap miners outperform given the significant commodity price leverage combined with moderating cost pressures and strong free cash flow generation. Australian small cap gold miners are now becoming a meaningful weight in the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries Index and given increasing cash balances, we expect further corporate activity to continue in the sector. Key stock beneficiaries of corporate activity include De Grey Mining and Spartan Resources which are pending takeover bids from Northern Star Mining and Ramelius Resources, respectively.

Other key themes from the quarter include:

• Banks: share prices for the big banks started to crack given increasing concerns regarding Net interest Margin (NIM) compression
• Index changes: passive investing and index changes driving stock volatility, notably for Life360 and Sigma Healthcare
• Corporate activity: continue to see a ramp-up with private equity and offshore companies arbitraging the opportunities at the ‘value’ end of the market, notably Insignia Financial and Mayne Pharma Group
• Corporate governance: concerns for founder led businesses continue to attract investor interest, notably Wistech Global and Mineral Resources
• Federal election: the election uncertainty going into May with the potential risk of a minority government will be a watchpoint for investors despite minimal policy differentiation between the major parties, outside of energy and climate change
• Reporting season volatility: share price volatility over the February 2025 reporting season for the Australian small caps market has been one of the most elevated in recent reporting season history with disproportionate company performance relative to consensus earnings revisions  

In summary, the thematic shifts and heightened market volatility is creating increased value adding opportunities for active Australian small cap managers that have a competitive information advantage.