Everything you need to know about gold in 2025: New highs or major downturn?
Gold has long been considered a safe haven for investors, prized for its resilience in times of economic uncertainty. In addition to this, its price movements are often influenced by a web of factors that can either strengthen or weaken its appeal.
Some of the usual factors that are associated with gold price weakness are presently at play in markets – yet the gold price continues to hover just below record highs. Is this time different? Can gold prosper despite the prevailing seemingly bearish set of demand drivers?
There’s plenty of reasons to believe this is the case, and if it is, that ASX listed gold stocks may be about to reap a “growing cash harvest” as major broker Goldman Sachs puts it in a new research note they just released on the sector.
Let’s take a closer look at the factors that typically drive gold prices up or down, why today’s environment of a strong gold price appears to be defying several historical norms, and in Part 2 tomorrow, which ASX gold stocks are best placed to take advantage of continued gold price strength.
Factors typically associated with gold price strength
1. Low or negative real interest rates
All things being equal (i.e., with respect to the other factors listed here) the level of real interest rates is the most critical factor in determining the gold price. The real rate is the nominal interest rate minus inflation. Markets generally use a benchmark long term bond yield as a proxy for the nominal interest rate, for example, the yield on the US 10-Year Treasury Bond.
Gold bullion doesn’t have a yield, more so, one probably will incur holding costs (e.g. security and insurance) when holding large amounts of it. This means that when real interest rates fall (i.e., due to lower nominal rates, a higher inflation rate, or a combination of both), the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets like gold falls.
This means there are fewer financial impediments to owning gold and taking advantage of its defensive characteristics, or other favourable demand-supply fundamentals.
2. High inflation concerns
This item follows on from above, but additionally given there is a general perception gold is a stable store of value, it means gold is seen by many as a hedge against inflation. Inflation erodes the purchasing power of regular (“fiat”) currencies, so when inflation fears rise, investors often flock to gold to preserve their purchasing power.
3. Weak US dollar
Gold is primarily priced in US dollars in financial markets. This means a weaker US dollar makes gold cheaper for overseas buyers, typically boosting its demand and helping push prices upward.
4. Geopolitical tensions and market volatility
For hundreds of years gold has been viewed as a safe-haven asset in times of heightened geopolitical risks or episodes of extreme stock market volatility. Any flight to safety in financial markets, or “risk aversion” as it is usually referred to by economists, tends to lift prices.
5. Central bank demand
Most central banks hold gold as part of their foreign exchange reserves (e.g., China holds around 5.5% of its US$3.2 trillion total foreign reserves in gold). There is a growing trend for global central banks to diversify away from the US dollar – long considered the global reserve currency. This growing “de-dollarisation” trend could provide an additional boost to gold prices.
Factors typically associated with gold price weakness
1. Rising real interest rates
The opposite of 1, above. As central banks raise interest rates and or as global inflation falls, the opportunity cost of owning gold increases.
Consider that major government bonds, for example US bonds, are considered by markets to be risk-free. Gold is widely accepted to be a safe haven asset, but it is not considered to be risk-free. This means as the rate that can be earned on risk free bonds increases, the costs associated with holding gold become increasingly punitive.
2. Stable or low inflation
This item follows on from above, but also, low rates of inflation reduce the opportunity cost of owning fiat currency. Investors are therefore more likely to hold fiat currency and use it to pursue higher-yielding opportunities in bonds, stocks, or other risk assets.
3. Strong US dollar
The opposite of 3, above. Gold tends to move inversely to the US dollar. When the US dollar strengthens significantly, gold becomes more expensive for foreign buyers, often reducing its global demand.
4. Positive economic outlook
During periods of robust economic growth, investors become risk seeking, therefore buying growth-oriented stocks and corporate bonds. Gold may see its relative safe-haven allure fade, causing investors to convert their gold into fiat to allow them to chase higher yielding / higher growth assets.
5. Reduced uncertainty or geopolitical calm
Gold thrives on uncertainty. When markets are calm and geopolitical tensions are low, gold’s safe-haven appeal wanes, generally leading the gold price to soften.
The current environment for gold
Let’s review the above five positive / negative factors for gold in light of the current macroeconomic and geopolitical environment.
1. Real interest rates - Positive or negative?
Yields on most benchmark long term bonds are currently rising, offering investors nearly 5% in some cases of risk-free yield over the next 10-years. In particular, note the yield on the US 10-Year Treasury Bond has increased from around 3.6% in September, to around 4.8%.
But! Remember its real yields that are important for the gold price. We must consider how expected inflation has changed during the run up in nominal yields since September. These have also risen steadily, from around 2% to nearly 2.5%.
Doing the maths, it’s clear that real interest rates did still rise over the last four months. More broadly, they have been rising since the beginning of 2022 as per the chart of the US 10-Year TIPS Yield, below. (TIPS stands for Treasury Inflation Protected Securities, which subtracts the 10-Year Breakeven Inflation Rate from the 10-Year Treasury Bond yield to provide an indication of the real yield of US 10-Year Treasury Bonds.)
For this reason – arguably usually the most important factor that determines the gold price, I suggest we must call a NEGATIVE here.
2. Inflation – Positive or negative?
This item follows on from above, inflation expectations have been rising steadily since September and appear to be in a solid uptrend. I suggest we call a POSITIVE here.
3. Weak US dollar – Positive or negative?
A picture tells a thousand words (see chart below). The US dollar is rocketing on a growing realisation the US economy won’t experience a hard post-COVID pandemic landing, and further, that an uptick in expansionary fiscal policy from the incoming Trump administration may spur even stronger growth down the track. I suggest we call a NEGATIVE here.
4. Geopolitical tensions and market volatility – Positive or negative?
Predicting the outcome of geopolitical tensions is at the best of times a difficult task. Doing so today is no different, however, there is growing hope / expectation that a Trump administration may be more likely to broker de-escalations in existing major global conflicts (e.g., in the Middle East and in Ukraine).
As for market volatility, this has spiked recently as stronger than expected data regarding the US economy has substantially pared back expectations of the timing and magnitude of Federal Reserve interest rate cuts.
The market consensus is that the Fed has largely finished its cutting cycle for now, or that at most one more 0.25% cut is on the cards. This is around 0.5%-0.75% less than the market was expecting just a few months ago (hence the rapid ascent in US 10-Year Treasury Bond yields!).
Longer term, a stronger US economy should in theory bolster stock market profits, reducing fears of overvaluations and potentially even alleviate some of the concerns around US government debt. Markets may soon shrug off their recent disappointment over rate cuts and respond more positively, thus reducing market volatility.
Bringing the Trump factor back into the discussion, there’s also potential for substantial geopolitical instability and market volatility should the proposed tariffs be implemented (or potentially more punitive variations on the theme!). A tough one, and there’s probably no right or wrong answer here – so I suggest we call a NEUTRAL here.
5. Central bank demand – Positive or negative?
This one appears clearer cut than many of the others. It is a widely held view that the US fiscal position is rapidly deteriorating, driving global central banks to diversify their reserves away from the US dollar. In practice, this generally means holding fewer US Treasuries, and this is contributing to the higher US bond yields discussed above (as bond yields fall, their yield rises).
China is leading the gold buying spree, adding another 300,000 ounces to its reserves in December which now totals 73.3 million ounces. More broadly, World Gold Council (“WGC”) data shows that central bank total net gold purchases in the September Quarter (December data has not been released yet) was 186 tonnes (6.5 million ounces) for a year to date 694 tonnes (24.5 million ounces).
The WGC notes that 2022 was a record year for central bank total net gold purchases (1,082 tonnes), and 2023 was the second largest on record (1,037 tonnes). Based on the run rate to the end of September, central bank net gold purchases were likely down again in 2024 but likely remained at a historically high level.
Let’s call a POSITIVE here.
Takeaways and ASX gold stocks' “growing cash harvest”
While gold’s performance typically aligns with certain macroeconomic conditions – real rates, the US dollar, inflation, geopolitical tensions and market volatility, and central bank activity – today’s environment shows these relationships are anything but set in stone.
Of our five major determining factors of gold price performance, arguably only two are set at POSITIVE (inflation and central bank activity). Yet the gold price continues to hover near all-time highs.
This is perhaps difficult to justify when one considers that the typically most-critical determining factor, real rates, appears firmly set against gold price strength. It’s even more incredible considering the surging US dollar.
But this is the conundrum of gold pricing at present. The gold price is holding strong – and this speaks to the potentially oversized impact of the simmering inflation threat, three years of ravenous central bank buying, and continued uncertainty surrounding geopolitical tensions and market volatility.
In conclusion, gold’s role as a safeguard against uncertainty remains a powerful force, even when other historical indicators appear to point the other way.
Stay tuned tomorrow for a deep dive into the ASX gold sector in which I’ll highlight the most highly rated gold stocks by major brokers and research houses.
This article first appeared on Market Index on Wednesday 15 January 2024.
5 topics