This economist has correctly predicted each of the RBA's last 12 moves. Here is how he does it
Every first Tuesday of the month at 2:30pm, everyone from mortgage holders to interest rate traders and economists collectively hold their breath for the Reserve Bank of Australia's monetary policy decision. And for those who live and breathe the in's and out's of monetary policy, it can get quite addictive. Predicting what Governor Lowe and his board will do and when can be considered akin to playing with fire but right calls can lead to million-dollar profits at some investment houses.
George Tharenou knows what it's like to wait with bated breath for the RBA's decision. As UBS' chief economist in Australia, it's Tharenou's job to write up the how's and why's for clients ahead of each meeting and following each meeting.
He also happens to be really good at calling them. He has predicted the central bank's next move every single month for the last year without fail (and he has the track record to prove it).
So how does he do it? And what can investors learn from the way he approaches rate decision calls? In this wire, you'll find out the answers to these and many other pressing questions.
Tharenou's background
Tharenou joined UBS in 2006 as senior economist after stints at the Reserve Bank and the Queensland Treasury.
Raised in Queensland and a graduate of the Queensland University of Technology, Tharenou admits he always had his sights set on this career path.
"I pretty much wanted to be a market economist from school," Tharenou candidly told me.
"I'm a black swan [among my family]. I was literally reading the AFR at primary school. That's a bit weird and a bit nerdy. But it was something that was just a passion for me. From a very young age, where I pretty much knew apart from wanting to be the cricket captain of Australia, that was my number one goal," he added.
Tharenou clinched the top job in 2017 after Scott Haslem left the post. Haslem is now CIO at LGT Crestone. He says his day-to-day doesn't always involve just sitting in front of the ABS website waiting for data to drop.
"A lot of it is judgement, and analytical thought beyond just the daily data flow and news and creating a narrative and a story for clients that's understandable," he said.
Why Tharenou predicted last week's RBA move would be a pause
Tharenou was one of the 19 economists in the Bloomberg survey to correctly predict last week's RBA move. Far more importantly, it kept Tharenou's winning streak of 12 consecutive and correct rate calls intact. He attributes his outperformance to understanding how changes in language from RBA Governor Philip Lowe impact policy.
"Market participants, both sell-side analysts and investors have really struggled to read the RBA in a timely manner, and be flexible in their rate views around that," he said while acknowledging the RBA's communication efforts have been less than stellar over the last two years.
"If you've had a rigid view on the RBA outlook based on history, or just month-to-month data prints, you would have probably got the calls wrong, rather than right," Tharenou added.
Tharenou actually argues that the RBA may have been looking for an excuse to pause its rate hiking cycle a second time as early as April this year.
"The RBA's pause in April was consistent with the idea that they were shifting their reaction function to be a more forward-looking assessment of the inflation outlook, rather than the backward looking data. And that meant that the board needed to be convinced that further tightening was required, and they would only have that occur after each quarterly inflation print," he said.
But as is with many things in central banking, what they do is not always what they should do. So does Tharenou think the RBA made the right call for the economy's sake?
"I think that the pause decision was the correct one in the sense that the RBA now has policy and at restrictive levels, and are requiring a hurdle that's greater for them to move rates up again. And I think that will be delivered in August, when the board's presented with inflation forecast, which is still above target next year," he said.
His decision making process
While a lot of his work involves data crunching, writing, and presenting views to clients, Tharenou says the real secret to calling the RBA's next move is to read between the lines - work out if changes to language are on purpose and will actually materially change the way they see policy moving forward.
"Go back to March [2023]. The RBA actually said that they were looking to pause and slow down the pace of rate rises, and the market ignored that commentary," he said.
"I remember also going back to October last year, when the RBA slowed down the pace of rate rises and he said that they we're considering a 25 or 50 at the last meeting and the market just ignored it as if he didn't say it. So, he told everyone he was looking to slow things down and then was heavily criticised when he did as a surprise," he added.
On communication and credibility
Tharenou is essentially arguing that in at least two instances, the RBA was providing some form of forward guidance without being too explicit. After all, they know first hand what it's like to suggest that rates won't rise for three years then get slapped in the face by inflation.
"I think there's a balance here, where they have to signal to the market that they're going to do something. But they can't be definitive, because at each board meeting, it's live, and they'll make that decision at that time," Tharenou pointed out.
This week, the Reserve Bank announced more reforms to its process including reducing the number of meetings it holds annually from 11 to 8. The meetings will also be longer and it will also implement post-meeting press conferences one hour after every decision.
But will any of those changes solve the RBA's credibility crisis? Tharenou gives a quick response.
"No," Tharenou said before adding "it may help the general public have a better understanding of the thought process of the Reserve Bank's decisions in real time."
Where he sees things now
12 months ago, Tharenou's 'terminal rate' (endgame) for the RBA would have been 2.5%. That figure is in line with what the RBA thought was the "neutral" rate (where the RBA thinks the policy rate should settle once all shocks have played out in an ideal world).
"A year ago, many had expected a much lower peak rate, and I think we've been surprised significantly by the persistence of global inflation as the primary factor for the reason why rates have increased more than expected. And the resilience of the global economy has been much greater as well," he said.
Now, Tharenou is calling for an 4.35% terminal rate, implying just one more rate hike in the months ahead. He also argues that the Bank will likely hold rates higher for longer, with his published research suggesting the first cut will only come in mid-2024.
"[Our] base case is 25 basis points more from the RBA, which has been a long held view. A peak rate in August is the most likely timing," he said. "I feel more comfortable that the likelihood is the RBA is signalling that they're more likely to do one, then multiple moves from here," he added.
Given Tharenou expects the Reserve Bank to hike next month (even if he does think it will be the last one), I also asked him about what the chances are of an Australian recession if the central bank were to keep hiking beyond his terminal forecast.
"UBS has been flagging the probability of a recession at 25%, simply based on the lags of policy, where the fixed rate mortgage cliff would start to hit the economy more materially from the middle of this year. We've been saying if the RBA continue rates rise from here, the probability is 50-50 of recession-overcoming quarters," he added.
3 topics